Home What’s New What to Look for in a Literary Agent: A Guide for Aspiring Authors

What to Look for in a Literary Agent: A Guide for Aspiring Authors

by Robert Johnson
Published: Updated:

Finding the right literary agent can be a game-changer for your writing career. Literary agents act as intermediaries between you and publishers, helping to secure book deals, negotiate contracts, and provide industry expertise. But not all agents are created equal. Choosing the wrong one can stall your career, while the right one can propel you forward. Here’s what to look for in a literary agent to ensure a successful partnership.

1. Experience and Track Record

A literary agent’s experience matters. Experienced agents understand the nuances of the publishing world and have built strong relationships with publishers and editors. They know what works and what doesn’t, and can advise you on how to position your manuscript in the market.

How to Evaluate Experience

  • Successful Track Record: Look for an agent who has sold books in your genre. Check their client list and the types of deals they’ve secured.
  • Industry Connections: A good agent should have a network of connections with editors and publishers. This can dramatically increase the chances of your manuscript getting read.
  • Client Success: Research the agent’s clients—are they publishing regularly? Are their books getting positive attention?

2. Passion for Your Work

A good literary agent should be excited about your writing. This passion will fuel their dedication to selling your book, pitching it to the right publishers, and navigating the often challenging publishing process.

How to Gauge Passion

  • Personal Interest: A great agent will take the time to get to know your work and your vision for the book. They should ask insightful questions about your manuscript and future projects.
  • Long-Term Interest: Ideally, an agent should see you as a long-term client, not just a one-book deal. They should show interest in building your career, not just making a quick sale.

3. Good Communication Skills

Clear, open communication is essential when working with a literary agent. You need someone who can provide feedback, updates, and guidance throughout the entire publishing process.

How to Evaluate Communication

  • Response Time: Pay attention to how quickly the agent responds to your initial queries. A quick, professional response is a good sign of their communication style.
  • Transparency: A trustworthy agent should be transparent about the publishing process, including timelines, expectations, and challenges. They should also be honest about why they think your work will or won’t sell.
  • Availability: While agents are often busy, they should be accessible for questions and updates. Make sure you’re comfortable with their level of availability.

4. Strong Negotiation Skills

One of the primary roles of a literary agent is to negotiate contracts on your behalf. The terms of a publishing deal can be complicated, and a skilled agent will ensure you get the best possible deal, not just in terms of money, but also rights, royalties, and other key aspects.

How to Evaluate Negotiation Skills

  • Deal Success: Research the deals the agent has negotiated for other clients. Do they typically secure good advances and favorable contract terms?
  • Industry Knowledge: A good agent should have a deep understanding of the publishing industry, including current trends, market demands, and what publishers are looking for.
  • Advocate for Your Interests: Your agent should prioritize your best interests, ensuring that your rights are protected and that you’re fairly compensated.

5. Honesty and Integrity

A good agent should always be upfront with you about your manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses, as well as the reality of the publishing process. Honesty and integrity are key to a successful working relationship.

How to Spot Honesty

  • Constructive Feedback: Look for an agent who can provide honest, constructive criticism without sugarcoating things. They should help you improve your work, not just flatter you to keep you as a client.
  • Transparency About Fees: Ensure the agent is clear about their commission (usually 15%) and any other fees. Be wary of agents who ask for upfront fees—this is a red flag, as reputable agents are paid on commission only, once a deal is made.
  • Clear Contracts: A good agent will offer clear, understandable contracts and will walk you through the terms.

6. Specialization in Your Genre

Not all agents are the same. Some specialize in specific genres, while others handle a wide range of writing styles. Finding an agent who is familiar with and passionate about your genre can make a huge difference in the success of your book.

How to Choose the Right Genre Agent

  • Expertise in Your Genre: Look for an agent who has a strong track record of selling books in your genre. For example, if you’re writing science fiction, find an agent who has connections with publishers that specialize in that area.
  • Understanding Your Market: Your agent should understand the readers and trends in your genre. They should be able to advise you on how to market your book effectively.

7. Reputation in the Industry

An agent’s reputation can have a significant impact on the success of your book. Agents with a strong reputation are more likely to get your manuscript noticed by publishers, and their endorsement can lend credibility to your work.

How to Check Reputation

  • Industry Recognition: Research the agent’s presence in the publishing community. Are they well-known at book fairs and industry events? Have they been recognized by major publishing outlets?
  • Client Testimonials: Look for feedback from other writers who have worked with the agent. Positive reviews, interviews, or case studies can give you insights into what it’s like to work with them.

8. Transparency on Process and Fees

It’s important to understand how the agent works and what services they provide. Make sure you’re clear on their commission, their expectations, and how they plan to represent you.

What to Expect

  • Commission: Literary agents usually take 15% commission on domestic sales and 20% for foreign sales. Avoid agents who charge upfront fees or higher-than-usual commissions.
  • Contract Length and Termination: Ensure the agent offers a fair contract with clear terms. If you’re unhappy with the relationship, it should be easy to terminate the agreement.

9. Compatibility with Your Goals

Ultimately, a literary agent should align with your career goals and values. They need to be someone you can trust to guide you through the ups and downs of the publishing world.

How to Gauge Compatibility

  • Shared Vision: An agent should understand your vision for your writing career, whether you’re aiming for a best-seller, a niche following, or a long-term literary career.
  • Work Style: Ensure your work styles align. Do you prefer frequent updates, or are you comfortable with a more hands-off approach? Make sure your expectations are in sync.

10. Patience and Persistence

The road to publishing can be long and challenging. A great agent will show persistence in pushing your manuscript to the right publishers, even if it takes time.

How to Spot Patience

  • Long-Term Commitment: A good agent will be committed to finding the right publisher for your book, no matter how long it takes. They should be ready to handle rejection and keep pursuing the right opportunities.
  • Support Through Setbacks: Rejection is part of the process. A patient agent will support you through setbacks and help you stay focused on the bigger picture.

Finding the Right Fit

Choosing the right literary agent is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as an author. A great agent can help you navigate the complexities of publishing, secure better deals, and build a successful career. When considering agents, focus on experience, passion for your work, communication skills, and their reputation within the industry. Above all, make sure you find someone who shares your vision, understands your goals, and is committed to your success.

Key Takeaways

  • Look for an agent with a strong track record and industry connections.
  • Choose someone who shows passion for your work and is interested in your long-term success.
  • Make sure they have clear communication, strong negotiation skills, and integrity.
  • Consider their experience with your genre, as this can be crucial for success.
  • Trust your instincts and ensure the agent is someone you feel comfortable working with long-term.

 

You may also like

Page&Quill

Discover new book releases, bestseller lists, and find out when your favorite author is making their next appearance.

We'll Make Your Inbox Worth Reading

Sign up to our newsletter for the latest news about books, authors, and more from Page&Quill.



By signing up, I confirm that I have reviewed and accept Page&Quill’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Page and Quill is part of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate program that allows sites to earn advertising fees by linking to Amazon.com.

©2025 All Right Reserved. Bookmark Publishing Company.